Thanks for the review, I'm glad you didn't let the anti 3D bias through.

My pleasure. Thanks for signing up!

LIST as of 12/08/10:
Upcoming:
When Pigs Fly
Thirteen Comics
The Mannequin Waltz
The Flaming Chicken

Fodder(when upcoming list is finished):
Jake the Evil Hare
A Deviant Mind


Next up is When Pigs Fly.

The review for When Pigs Fly is here!

Next up is Thirteen Comics.

I really like your reviews, to the point that my fragile ego is permitting me to request a review of A Cat's Tale.

Thanks in advance.

I wouldn't mind a review. The pages up so far were coloured with a mouse *shudder* but my tablet is secretly plotting my demise. The comic is called In All Things. It gets weird at page -1. http://www.drunkduck.com/In_All_Things/

*after reading today's author's notes* uhhh on second thought please wait until after the holidays to review mine thankies!

Here's my last review.

My only critique about this review thing is the 25-50 page limit. There's many comics that have had shaky starts and may take about 100 or more installments to get into their groove. I know my comic looked real rough at the beginning, and you could see quite a difference in appearance between then and now as my technique improved.

I understand your reluctance to click through hundreds of archive pages… I just feel that you're cheating yourself out of some excellent comics with those limits, and that you're only gonna be looking at comics that have yet to “gel”.

Maybe instead of stipulating “25 or 50-count series only”, you could state that you're only going to pore over the last 25-30 updates of a comic. Just a friendly suggestion. :)

I think this comic really is a good idea. It takes away all the controlling “draw 500 realistic apples by monday” aspects while keeping the intellectual critiques on what we should work on without, in most cases, offensiveness. there is the constructive criticism even in the case of 13comics it was a “you need to stop all this-you just gestured to all of me!”(HTTYD)way. Great Idea putting it in an amusing form too, and showing what could be improved.

Don't review my review comic. You're tearing the fabric of the universe!!!
Nah really, thanks for the comments.

@Zenny: Appreciate it. I'll try to keep it amusing and improve too. Although I never saw that movie, if in fact you are referring to that movie?

@PyThomas: Thanks for the suggestion and of course I understand what you are saying. But to me that's exactly why I want to keep it at that limit. Normally the page limit to participate in anything reviews or otherwise and not just on DD, is over 20 pages. I figured I'd give the baby comics a place to participate in something. Also I figure its a good way of letting budding comics know if they are on the right track and can gather a tiny bit more readers whilst it is first starting out. Maybe they can ‘gel’ faster. That is if I offer any good advice. I hope to do that at least.


LIST as of 12/23/10:
Upcoming:
The Mannequin Waltz
The Flaming Chicken
A Cat's Tale
TCMB
In All Things

Fodder(when upcoming list is finished):
Jake the Evil Hare
A Deviant Mind


Next up is The Mannequin Waltz.

Don't bother revewing my comic I'm restarting it.

Nergal, I like that the reviews are for baby comics. It's unique and it's an important stage to get some good feedback/criticism in. :]

Can you add the Hero Factor to the list please.

I didn't get to thanking you for the review yet.
Thank you.
I enjoy reviews no matter what happens to be said in them

-1337/funnyman

I Am The 1337 Master
I didn't get to thanking you for the review yet.
Thank you.
I enjoy reviews no mettaur what happens to be said in them

-1337/funnyman

Did someone mention me? :D

Get out of here hijacker!!!! Just kidding. It doesn't matter to me.


The review for Mannequin Waltz is up. I also updated a story page about the new review bot. Check it out yo!

@funnyman: Anytime! Thanks!

Next up is The Flaming Chicken.

LIST as of 12/28/10:
Upcoming:
The Flaming Chicken
A Cat's Tale
In All Things
The Hero Factor

Fodder(when upcoming list is finished):
Jake the Evil Hare
A Deviant Mind

Let me know if I'm missing anything?

Hello Nergal! Thankyou so much for the review! I loved it, and I do apologize for not reading it earlier because I'm usually not at home on weekdays. But still, its always been a pleasure reading your review comic. Thanks again. =D

I know I have more than 25 pages, but since I am a strip, maybe there's wiggle room on this one?

http://www.drunkduck.com/Why_Does_Everyone_Hate_My_Guts/index.php?p=780626
]Check out the review for The Flaming Chicken!

@vidihawk I can add you to the alternate list if you want.
@theshazerin No problem, thanks for signing up and reading.

Next up is A Cat Tale.

LIST as of 01/05/11:
Upcoming:
A Cat's Tale
In All Things
The Hero Factor

Fodder(when upcoming list is finished):
Jake the Evil Hare
A Deviant Mind

Also updates normally happen on Tuesday sometime after 9pm EST
But do understand that I have one of the worst jobs in the world so it's not always 100% on time. ;D Thanks for reading and signing up!

:) I am totally ok with an alt-list.

wow, been a while since I've posted on the forum…of any kind here on DD.

I'd Like either Nintendo's Untold Legends or Journey of the Pirate Kings

NUL has been going on for almost 4 years now, but I know I could probably improve somewhere.

JotPK has been going on for a little over a year, but maybe some critiques on my Fanfic Cross Over.

The review for A Cat Tale is up!

LIST as of 01/11/11:
Upcoming:
In All Things
The Hero Factor

Fodder(when upcoming list is finished):
Jake the Evil Hare
A Deviant Mind
RPS
Journey of the Pirate Kings
Nintendo's Untold Legends


Up next is In All Things.

Hi Nergal. Thanks very much for the review!

of course I loved it – I really appreciate the absolute lack of “nit-picky” while still mentioning a definite area where it can be improved.

It's probably the most generous and gentle review Ever (um – who did you say I make the check out to? )

I'd love to have you review Modest Medusa.

Okay lets try this I throw Todd Sweets the worst comic on DD to you're wolves!

The review for In All Things is up.

Due to a change in my work schedule. Updates will be appearing on Sundays for now.

LIST as of 01/30/11:
Upcoming:
The Hero Factor
Modest Medusa
Todd Sweets

Fodder(when upcoming list is finished):
Jake the Evil Hare
A Deviant Mind
RPS
Journey of the Pirate Kings
Nintendo's Untold Legends

Thanks for signing up!

Up next is The Hero Factor.

@ayesinback: No problem. Thanks for signing up. Hmm don't know if I like being called “gentle”…I prefer honest. : D

I don't care if you're harsh - I need to hear it to improve.
Review my newest comic, Impossible Quest: www.drunkduck.com/comics/I/Impossible_Quest.
It's got one page, but I have a stock of pages that I am posting regularly. By the time you've got through all those reviews, this'll probably have lots of pages. Sooo, yeah. Go ahead and be mean to me.

Nergal
Hmm don't know if I like being called “gentle”…I prefer honest. : D

:) Honest is Best! but that you typically avoid harshness in your reviews, imo, is a rare and welcome trait.

I can tell you that your review of my comic has made me want to take it a little more seriously and do what I can to improve. so sincere thanks.

Thank you so much for the review,
if you believe it this is the first critisism I actually recieved… and that lack got on my nerves.
…well that was technically a lie but I thought the one time was because I tried to teach that person how to read Manga the day before, so they didn't know the order.
Under construction is a great way to put it, I have a lot of detailed blueprints but I have to teach myself bricklaying… it's good to have the quality control people in occasionally.
I imagine in later years… no wait That was also a lie I go OH GODS NO when looking at the earlier stuff now.
May the force be with you
Annika

PS I wonder if It is possible to get high on critisism… this is so unlike me

Here's the review for The Hero Factor

@Annika Keep on working. You're on a good path. Thanks for signing up.
@ayesinback I'm glad to hear that my review can help motivate. That's sort of what I'm aiming for.

Anyway thanks to everyone for reading and remember you can always check out the comics yourselves to form your own opinion. Perhaps you don't think like me and have your own insight. Which makes me curious. How many people find they don't like my taste?

Anyway next up is Modest Medusa.

I'd love for you to review my comic Philosophical Penis Jokes.