Aghammer
Dude, I think everyone reads your comic :)
I saw the same thing in Skool's comics but the clues were not that clear or exact… Drasnus was a partial fit as well.
On the other hand, while we did have some clues that people linked to me (b&w, knife)… it would have been nice if the killer used a sword… NO more knives people! :D The red herrings were as strong as the clues at times.
I didn't intentionally make any red herrings, but there were bound to be some or the clues would be too precise. Granted, my style of writing and love of weapons and soldiering made me put some in such as the combat knife and the wakazashi, which were intended to point to Prank (black and white and the blacksmith). And since nobody linked the weapon repairing to one offhand comment Skool made about Fallout3, that wasn't too good a tie in either.
In hindsight I see a lot of things that ended up unintentionally misleading and others that simply weren't strong clues, so whomever is GM next, learn from my mistakes! (And for the love of God, get the rules straight before you start the game :X