a cat goes for the neck only when it's hungry, because a lot of muscles exist there, and muscles taste good

OK. Let's check out everyone's profile and check for clues!

martinlo_23
Wait, it killed in the neck isn't it?

It was never said how the victim was killed. It was written in a style where you have to read into it and make some general assumptions.
A simple ‘was found dead, fork wounds to the neck believed to be the cause’ would've been nice though.

Sea_Cow

martinlo_23

Niccea
You can't kill unless you are mafia or vigilante. If you are neither, you have to vote to lynch someone after 9pm EST.

I can say what role I am here?Townies are like vigilantes or only the vigilante can kill? And lynching is like saying who is a mafioso? Oh si! Spanish lol

Actually, I'd prefer if you spoke English.

Too bad :gem:

do any of you people even own cats

…
Check out Skoolmunkee's comic:

http://www.drunkduck.com/The_Old_Woman_and_Her_Pig/index.php?p=448088

Wait, It could be Gasp Its Jake because of liking the neck could be vampiric and Jake has Hatpire avatar and that could mena he likes vampires. That + clues = Possible killer
Oh yeah.It's my birthday.Oh yeah.I get it.Oh yeah.

leaderofstars
do any of you people even own cats

i have 8 and none of them have ever even scratched me, well lay lay did by accident once, but she started crying afterwards so is'okay.

Mhhhh….skool being possible mafia AND pardoner?? Not good…

Happy birthday.

———-
Anyway, yes, it could be him, but Harokvast is chef suspect since he was the one calling out korosu.

Skoolmunkee has an anthropomorphic pig in her comic though…

ozoneocean
…
Check out Skoolmunkee's comic:

http://www.drunkduck.com/The_Old_Woman_and_Her_Pig/index.php?p=448088

Can comics be used as clues or evidence?
Was research actually done for this? Cause I didn't think it was that organized that all our comics and profiles would have been read. But then again maybe.
I just don't know the rules for all this.

I hate that.

ozoneocean
Happy birthday.

———-
Anyway, yes, it could be him, but Harokvast is chef suspect since he was the one calling out korosu.

Skoolmunkee has an anthropomorphic pig in her comic though…

It's not my birthday. It's October 14.
Im 11.

it was a dream nothing else

Vakanai

ozoneocean
…
Check out Skoolmunkee's comic:

http://www.drunkduck.com/The_Old_Woman_and_Her_Pig/index.php?p=448088

Can comics be used as clues or evidence?
Was research actually done for this? Cause I didn't think it was that organized that all our comics and profiles would have been read. But then again maybe.
I just don't know the rules for all this.

Yes we can use profiles etc. Black Kitty gave an example of that before :)

as well as avatar picures

Vakanai

ozoneocean
…
Check out Skoolmunkee's comic:

http://www.drunkduck.com/The_Old_Woman_and_Her_Pig/index.php?p=448088

Can comics be used as clues or evidence?
Was research actually done for this? Cause I didn't think it was that organized that all our comics and profiles would have been read. But then again maybe.
I just don't know the rules for all this.

hmmmm…*thinking of making a comic about mafia and getting a lot of pageviews* :)

Gasp Its Jake - 1 vote
harkovast

leaderofstars - 1 vote
martinlo_23

harkovast - 4 votes
leaderofstars
Ozoneocean


Right now Harkovast is in the lead~ Now I read the thread and see if I need to answer questions.

Well, since no one answered my questions, I went back to the first page of the sign up thread and found this:
Paranoid
While pro-town, the paranoid is a wee bit unhinged by his experiences in the war. The Paranoid will kill whoever was the first person to target him in any way during the night, whether it be mafia or villager (such as a paramedic opting to protect him). The Paranoid is unable to NOT kill, but will only kill one person a night.

The paranoid doesn't have to kill every night, but that last little bit had confused me into thinking the paranoid had to kill once every night. You can see how I could get confused.
Anyways, it now seems more likely that the kill was mafia. Possibly vigilante killing who he thinks is mafia, but that is unlikely so soon.

As I understand it, the two main suspects are:
1. Leaderofstars, because of the cannibalism threat.
2. Harkovast, for claiming whoever died was mafia or some such for some reason (I wasn't really paying attention).
Skoolmunkee and 2ndredbaron are also possible suspects, but are highly unlikely (the only evidence being the pig comic and the plane thing).
We should make a list of all suspects and all the evidence that points to them for easy reference.

Maybe Harkvoast is the murderer because of lynching.

Well i'm gonna rest bye to all.

P.S.:Don't solve this case without me.

or Harkvoast killed him as so not to make it seem that Harkvoast is in fact: mafia

I've voted.
I say Harkovast.

Even if it wasn't him, he made up evidence against korosu, that means he's just going to be messing us around and confusing things. Working against us like mafia would anyway, even if he's not one of then.

leaderofstars
it was a dream nothing else

True, almost all of the dream sequence could have been planted as a red herring. I mean, there was a lot of odd and vague nonsense stuff that could have easily been designed for the sole reason of keeping us guessing, and I did find us being told dream stuff to be a rather odd clue. However I'm pretty sure that the part with the murderer with the fork and napkin to be the real clues, which brings us back to suspecting you leaderofstars, since the cannibalism thing most strongly points to you (to be fair, cannibalism did feature with me once in War of the Bands, but there was no fork and it is widely believed I ate the cat ). Just saying, if we ignore the dream sequence, then it doesn't look good for los.

ozoneocean

Vakanai

ozoneocean
…
Check out Skoolmunkee's comic:

http://www.drunkduck.com/The_Old_Woman_and_Her_Pig/index.php?p=448088

Can comics be used as clues or evidence?
Was research actually done for this? Cause I didn't think it was that organized that all our comics and profiles would have been read. But then again maybe.
I just don't know the rules for all this.

Yes we can use profiles etc. Black Kitty gave an example of that before :)

Good to know, thanks.

Vote tally updated again~ (See above)

I have also put in the role descriptions on the first post of the thread so it's easier to access.

The Paranoid possess a passive ability that he/she cannot control. The first person to do an action on a Paranoid at night will get hit by the Paranoid preemptively. This is a night ability however so during the day it is safe to target the Paranoid.

Remember that clues are based on avatar, profile, and signature. There are always going to be true clues within the narrative but beware also of red herrings/coincidences.

look as far as we know the victim was killed by a ripped out throat.
i go for the heart and when my prey is awake. besides if it was me i would not hide it. i would write my name on a nearby wall with the words “did this” in blood

Black_Kitty
Vote tally updated again~ (See above)

I have also put in the role descriptions on the first post of the thread so it's easier to access.

The Paranoid possess a passive ability that he/she cannot control. The first person to do an action on a Paranoid at night will get hit by the Paranoid preemptively. This is a night ability however so during the day it is safe to target the Paranoid.

Remember that clues are based on avatar, profile, and signature. There are always going to be true clues within the narrative but beware also of red herrings/coincidences.

What about things people say/post? Can clues be based on that?

yes i'm sure

Vakanai
What about things people say/post? Can clues be based on that?

No because the clues become too vague if that's the case. :( You guys could be writing about anything and everything. So I generally go for profile, avatar, and signature.

Black_Kitty

Vakanai
What about things people say/post? Can clues be based on that?

No because the clues become too vague if that's the case. :( You guys could be writing about anything and everything. So I generally go for profile, avatar, and signature.

Hey leaderofstars, you just got knocked off my prime suspect list.